Russell Wilson’s tenure with the Pittsburgh Steelers in the 2024 NFL season marked a pivotal chapter in both his career and the team’s ongoing quest for quarterback stability. After a tumultuous stint with the Denver Broncos, Wilson joined the Steelers on a one-year, veteran-minimum contract, aiming to prove he could still perform at an elite level.
This article explores Wilson’s journey with the Steelers, the team’s 2024 season, his performance, the transition to Aaron Rodgers in 2025, and the lingering questions fans have been asking on platforms like YouTube and Google. Drawing from the latest web sources, we’ll delve into the highs, lows, and what’s next for Wilson and the Steelers.
The Arrival of Russell Wilson in Pittsburgh
In March 2024, the Pittsburgh Steelers made headlines by signing Russell Wilson, a nine-time Pro Bowl quarterback and Super Bowl champion, to a one-year deal. The move came after Wilson’s challenging two-year stint with the Denver Broncos, where he struggled to replicate the success he enjoyed with the Seattle Seahawks. The Steelers, desperate for a reliable quarterback since Ben Roethlisberger’s retirement in January 2022, saw Wilson as a low-risk, high-reward option, especially since the Broncos were still paying the bulk of his salary due to offset clauses in his contract.
The signing was met with a mix of excitement and skepticism. Posts on X from early March 2024 reflected optimism about Wilson’s potential fit, with reports indicating mutual interest and a “very positive” meeting with the Steelers. However, some fans and analysts questioned whether Wilson, at 35 years old, could return to his Seattle-era form or if he was past his prime.
The Steelers’ Quarterback Room Overhaul
The Steelers didn’t stop at Wilson. They also acquired Justin Fields from the Chicago Bears in a trade for a late-round pick, creating a revamped quarterback room that included Wilson, Fields, Kyle Allen, and undrafted rookie John Rhys Plumlee. This overhaul signaled a clear intent from head coach Mike Tomlin and general manager Omar Khan to address the team’s quarterback woes, which had persisted since Roethlisberger’s departure. The addition of Wilson and Fields sparked debates about who would emerge as the starter, with Wilson initially favored due to his experience.
Russell Wilson’s 2024 Season with the Steelers
Wilson started 11 games for the Steelers in 2024, completing 64% of his passes for over 2,400 yards, 16 touchdowns, and five interceptions. While these numbers were solid, they didn’t fully silence critics who labeled him as “washed” after his Denver tenure. His time to throw averaged 2.86 seconds, slightly slower than Aaron Rodgers’ 2.69 seconds but faster than Fields’ 3.04 seconds, indicating he still possessed quick decision-making skills.
Wilson’s leadership and veteran presence were praised, but his performance was inconsistent down the stretch. The Steelers’ offense struggled at times, and Wilson was often scapegoated for the team’s inability to break through their postseason ceiling, a recurring issue for Pittsburgh in recent years. Despite earning his tenth Pro Bowl nod, some argued he was living off reputation rather than current production.
Play-Calling Tensions with Arthur Smith
One of the most discussed aspects of Wilson’s 2024 season was his rumored friction with offensive coordinator Arthur Smith. Reports surfaced in February 2025 that Smith restricted Wilson’s ability to change plays at the line of scrimmage, particularly after a game against the Cincinnati Bengals.
This led to speculation of a “clash of minds” between the two. However, Smith later addressed these rumors at minicamp, dismissing them as overblown and denying any significant drama. Some reports suggested these claims originated from Wilson’s camp, but the narrative was quickly quashed by Steelers insiders.
This tension, whether real or exaggerated, became a talking point on YouTube, with fans and analysts debating whether Smith’s play-calling limited Wilson’s effectiveness or if Wilson’s style didn’t mesh with the Steelers’ offensive scheme. Videos titled “Did Arthur Smith HOLD BACK Russell Wilson?” and “Russell Wilson vs. Steelers OC: What Really Happened?” gained traction, reflecting public curiosity about their dynamic.
The Justin Fields Question
Another major storyline was the competition between Wilson and Justin Fields. The Steelers initially leaned on Fields, who made six starts in 2024, but ultimately reverted to Wilson as the primary starter. This decision sparked debate about whether the Steelers mishandled Fields, a younger quarterback with potential to be a long-term solution.
Some analysts argued that benching Fields in favor of a 35-year-old Wilson was a shortsighted move, potentially marking the end of Fields’ tenure in Pittsburgh. YouTube content creators echoed this sentiment, with videos like “Did Mike Tomlin Give Up on Justin Fields Too Soon?” drawing thousands of views.
The Transition to Aaron Rodgers in 2025
The Steelers’ quarterback landscape shifted dramatically in the 2025 offseason when they signed four-time MVP Aaron Rodgers to a one-year, $13 million deal, effectively replacing Wilson and Fields. Rodgers, who had spent 2024 with the New York Jets, was seen as a significant upgrade, with analysts noting he could be the best quarterback Pittsburgh had since Roethlisberger’s prime.
This move was part of a broader roster overhaul, including blockbuster trades for wide receiver DK Metcalf and cornerback Jalen Ramsey, as well as signings like safety Juan Thornhill and tight end Jonnu Smith. The Steelers were clearly “all-in” for 2025, aiming to capitalize on the final years of stars like T.J. Watt and Cameron Heyward.
Wilson’s Departure to the Giants
Following the Rodgers signing, Wilson moved to the New York Giants, joining a quarterback room that included Jameis Winston and rookie Jaxson Dart. His one-year stint with the Steelers ended without the career resurgence he had hoped for, and he now faces a new challenge in New York, where he’s expected to compete for the starting role.
However, insiders like Ian Rapoport have predicted that Dart may eventually overtake Wilson as the Giants’ QB1. YouTube videos such as “Russell Wilson’s LAST CHANCE with the Giants?” and “Will Jaxson Dart Steal Russell Wilson’s Job?” have fueled discussions about his future.
The Steelers’ 2025 Outlook Without Wilson
The Steelers’ 2025 season is shaping up to be a defining one. With Rodgers at the helm, a receiving corps led by DK Metcalf, and a bolstered secondary featuring Jalen Ramsey, Darius Slay, and Juan Thornhill, Pittsburgh is poised for a deep playoff run. Analysts like Adam Schein have reversed earlier predictions of a losing season, now declaring the Steelers “officially back” as contenders.
However, not all are convinced. Former NFL player Andrew Hawkins expressed skepticism about the Rodgers-Metcalf pairing, citing the lack of a strong WR2 to draw defensive attention. YouTube discussions have echoed this concern, with some creators questioning whether Calvin Austin III can fill the role of a reliable second receiver, as Wilson once compared him to Tyler Lockett.
The Cost of Going All-In
The Steelers’ aggressive offseason moves came at a price. Trading safety Minkah Fitzpatrick to acquire Ramsey and Jonnu Smith was a shock, with Cameron Heyward admitting it was tough to say goodbye to a defensive cornerstone. These moves reflect GM Omar Khan’s determination to win now, but they’ve also sparked YouTube debates about whether the Steelers are mortgaging their future for a short-term shot at glory.
Russell Wilson’s Legacy with the Steelers
Wilson’s time in Pittsburgh was short but significant. He brought stability to a quarterback room that had been in flux since Roethlisberger’s retirement, and his veteran presence helped guide a young roster. However, his inability to consistently elevate the offense and the team’s subsequent pivot to Rodgers suggest that his impact fell short of expectations. YouTube retrospectives often frame Wilson’s 2024 season as a “what could have been” story, with fans split between those who admired his professionalism and those who felt he underperformed.
Comparisons to Aaron Rodgers
Interestingly, DK Metcalf, who played with Wilson in Seattle and now with Rodgers in Pittsburgh, noted similarities between the two quarterbacks, particularly in their leadership and decision-making. However, Rodgers’ superior 2024 stats and quicker release time have led most analysts to view him as a clear upgrade. YouTube comparisons like “Russell Wilson vs. Aaron Rodgers: Who’s Better for the Steelers?” highlight this shift, with many favoring Rodgers for his proven track record.
FAQs
What was Wilson’s performance like during the 2024 season?
Wilson started 11 games for the Steelers in the 2024 regular season, throwing for 2,482 yards, 16 touchdowns, and 5 interceptions. He led the team to a 10–3 record before a four-game losing streak. Despite the team’s late-season struggles, Wilson was named to the Pro Bowl as a replacement, marking his tenth selection.
Why did Wilson leave the Steelers?
Despite expressing a desire to return to Pittsburgh, Wilson ultimately signed a one-year, $10.5 million deal with the New York Giants in March 2025. Reports indicated that the Steelers were unlikely to re-sign him due to a less-than-ideal working relationship with offensive coordinator Arthur Smith, including restrictions on his ability to call audibles.
How did Wilson’s departure affect the Steelers’ quarterback situation?
Following Wilson’s departure, the Steelers signed veteran quarterback Aaron Rodgers to a one-year deal. However, oddsmakers remain skeptical about the team’s prospects, with low expectations for the 2025 season.
Has Russell Wilson talked about winning a Super Bowl with the Steelers?
Yes. In his introductory press conference, Wilson said he’s “here to win” and that he believes in the Steelers’ championship culture. While the team isn’t a top Super Bowl favorite, Wilson brings valuable playoff experience to a young roster.
Is this Russell Wilson’s last chance in the NFL?
Many insiders view this as a make-or-break season for Wilson. If he fails in Pittsburgh, it’s unlikely he will get another starting job elsewhere. But if he succeeds, he could extend his career for a few more years as a starter or high-end backup.
In Summary
Russell Wilson’s 2024 season with the Pittsburgh Steelers was a rollercoaster of hope, scrutiny, and transition. While he brought veteran leadership and solid stats, his tenure was overshadowed by inconsistency, play-calling tensions, and the team’s bold move to sign Aaron Rodgers for 2025. As Wilson embarks on a new journey with the Giants, the Steelers are gearing up for a high-stakes season with a revamped roster.
Fans continue to dissect Wilson’s Pittsburgh chapter on YouTube and Google, asking whether he was underutilized, fairly evaluated, or simply past his prime. One thing is certain: Wilson’s time with the Steelers will remain a fascinating footnote in his storied career and the team’s ongoing quest for a seventh Super Bowl.
To read more, Click Here
